Almost everyone who prays for long enough reaches a stretch where nothing seems to happen. The words go up and nothing comes back. The Bible that used to speak reads like a telephone directory. You keep turning up, and it feels like talking to the ceiling.

This is so common that the Christian tradition has several names for it. The desert fathers called it acedia. Spiritual writers speak of dryness, or of desolation. St John of the Cross wrote a whole book on what he called the dark night. The fact that it has a vocabulary tells you something: you are not the first, and it is not a sign that you have done something wrong.

A journal is useful in these seasons in a particular way. Not because writing makes God feel near again, which it may not, but because it keeps you honest and keeps you turning up. And months later, it shows you the shape of a season you could not see from inside.

Before you start

Do not perform. The temptation in a dry season is to write the kind of entry you think you ought to write. Write the true one instead. "I feel nothing" is an honest prayer.

Keep it short. Long entries in a dry season tend to become essays about the dryness. Three lines is plenty.

Keep the time, even when it is empty. The tradition is unanimous on this. Turning up when it costs you something is not wasted. It may be the most real prayer you ever pray.

Saying it plainly

  1. Write, to God, that He feels far away. Use whatever words are true.
  2. How long has it felt like this?
  3. What did prayer used to feel like? What is different now?
  4. What are you afraid the silence means?
  5. What do you want from God right now, if you are honest?
  6. Copy out Psalm 13:1–2. Notice that it is in the Bible.
  7. Write "My God, my God, why…" from Psalm 22, and finish the sentence in your own words.

Looking for causes, gently

Sometimes dryness has an ordinary explanation. Sometimes it has none. These prompts look, without assuming there must be a fault.

  1. How are you sleeping? Eating? Is your body exhausted?
  2. What has changed in your life in the last three months?
  3. Is there something you are avoiding saying to God?
  4. Is there a relationship that needs mending?
  5. Has your prayer become a habit you get through rather than a meeting?
  6. What would you change about how you pray, if you could change one thing?
  7. Is this dryness, or is it grief or depression? Who could help you tell the difference?

Praying without feeling

  1. Pray the Lord's Prayer slowly and write one phrase that stood out.
  2. Copy out a psalm in full, and let it be your prayer today.
  3. Write what you believe, not what you feel. Start with the Creed if you need to.
  4. Pray for three other people by name and write their names down.
  5. Write one thing you will keep doing even if nothing changes.
  6. Sit for five minutes in silence before writing anything. Then write the date and "I was here."

Remembering

  1. When did you last feel close to God? Describe it in detail.
  2. Read an old journal entry from a better season. Write a line back to the person who wrote it.
  3. List five times God has been faithful to you.
  4. What did you learn in the last dry season, if there was one?
  5. Who in your life has been through this and come out the other side?
  6. Copy out Lamentations 3:21–23. Write today's date beside it.

Waiting

  1. What would you like to be true, even if you cannot feel it?
  2. What is God possibly doing in you that you cannot see?
  3. If this season lasted a year, how would you want to spend it?
  4. Write a prayer for patience, and nothing else.
  5. Copy out Psalm 42:11. Note how the psalmist argues with himself.
  6. Write one line of hope, even if you only half mean it.

What the tradition says

You are in good company.

  • The psalmists wrote some of the bleakest lines in Scripture. Psalm 88 ends with darkness as the psalmist's only companion, and it was kept in the Bible anyway.
  • Jesus prayed "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" from the cross, quoting Psalm 22.
  • St John of the Cross taught that the dark night can be God drawing a soul past the comforts of feeling into a deeper trust.
  • St Ignatius of Loyola advised that in desolation you should never change a good decision made in consolation, and should keep your prayer, if anything, slightly longer.
  • Many later Christians have described long years of feeling nothing in prayer while continuing faithfully in it.

None of this makes the silence pleasant. It does mean the silence is a known country, with maps, and people who have walked out of it.

Common questions

Does feeling far from God mean I have lost my faith?

No. Faith is not a feeling; it is trust, and trust is most visible precisely when feeling is absent. Someone who keeps praying in a dry season is exercising more faith than someone who prays because it feels wonderful. The fact that the distance troubles you is itself a sign that you care about God.

Is spiritual dryness a punishment?

The tradition generally says no. Sometimes dryness has a cause worth looking at, such as an unconfessed sin, exhaustion, grief or a life that has become too crowded. Often it has no cause you will ever find. Spiritual writers have long described dry seasons as part of the normal life of prayer, and sometimes as a sign of growth rather than failure.

Should I stop praying until the feeling comes back?

Every serious writer on prayer says the opposite. Keep the time, keep it short and keep it honest. If you need to, change the form: pray the psalms, use a written prayer, walk while you pray. The one thing not to do is stop.

How do I know if this is depression rather than dryness?

They can overlap, and it is worth taking seriously. If the flatness is in every part of your life and not just prayer, if you have lost interest in things you used to enjoy, or if you are struggling to sleep, eat or work, please talk to your doctor as well as to your pastor. Caring for your body and mind is part of caring for your soul.

Devout gives you something to pray with when you have nothing of your own. Each morning there is a passage of Scripture, a short reflection from your tradition, and a question to write about, with a private journal on the same page.

Your old entries stay searchable, so on a dry morning you can read what a better one was like. Try Devout free for seven days.